Shopping in South Otselic, NY Otselic Valley Garage1603 Rt-26South Otselic, NY, 131553156537279Auto Repair ServiceCar WashGalf Little Tire RepairGas StationsNon Ethanol Gas StationsOil ChangeThe BarnThe Body Shop South Otselic Store1597 State Highway 26South Otselic, NY, 131553156537286Amish MarketGrocery StoresPine Ridge GroceriesShoppingWaldbaums Show MoreSee AlsoGrocery StoresMarketsFurniture StoresOutlet StoresSupermarkets & Super Stores