Grocery Stores in South Otselic, NY South Otselic Store1597 State Highway 26South Otselic, NY, 131553156537286Amish MarketGrocery StoresPine Ridge GroceriesShoppingWaldbaumsSouth Otselic StoreRoute 26South Otselic, NY, 131553156537286GrocerySuper 8Supermarkets Super StoresWeis MarketsShow More