Fish & Seafood Markets in Water Mill, NY Citarella760 Montauk HwyWater Mill, NY, 119766317263636Bobs Fish MarketCrabCrabsFish MarketsFish Seafood MarketsGreenport Crab Seafood CoCoastal Farms IncMIDDLE Line HwyWater Mill, NY, 119766312833154CrabsFish MarketFish MarketsFish Seafood WholesaleGreenport Crab Seafood CoSeafood BargeSeafood MarketSeafood MarketsTwo Cousins Fish MarketShow MoreSee AlsoLobsters