Gift Shops in Shelter Island, NY Cornucopia Gift Shop27 W Neck RdShelter Island, NY, 119646317490171ChristmasGift ShopsIrish StoresSouthhampton Gift ShopsSouvenir ShopsStationery Stores Molly Brown Boutique21 N Ferry RdShelter Island, NY, 119646317495539BoutiqueChristmasClothing BoutiquesGift ShopsIrish StoresSouthhampton Gift ShopsSouvenir Shops Show More