Dessert Restaurants in Newcomerstown, OH Chilly Willy's401 W State StNewcomerstown, OH, 438327404988681Amish RestaurantsCountry Ice Cream FreezerFrozen YogurtIce Cream Frozen DessertsManufacturing CompaniesTake Out RestaurantsUsed Restaurant Equipment Supplies Show MoreSee AlsoIce Cream & Frozen DessertsYogurt