Candy Stores in Montauk, NY Fudge N StuffTHE PlzMontauk, NY, 119546316684724Bulk CandyCandy Mold StoreCandy Store Sweet Tauk34 S Etna AveMontauk, NY, 119546316685683Bulk CandyCandy Mold StoreCandy StoreIce CreamSunset GrillToppers Ice Cream Show More