Shopping in Garrattsville, NY Painted Goat Farm371 Mittedorf RdGarrattsville, NY, 133426073213191Cheese FactoryCheese ShopCheese StoreDairy ProductsEgg FarmFarmsHeller FarmsPrudential Paul White Life Insurance Financial ServicesPumpkin FarmPumpkin FarmsWorm Farms Show MoreSee AlsoCandy Stores