Donut Shops in New Carlisle, OH Cake Creations Supply Shop11983 W National RdNew Carlisle, OH, 453449378451914BakeriesBakeryBirthday CakesCake BakeryCake Creations Supply ShopCake Supply StoreCupcake BakeryCupcakesDonutsStevens Bakery And OrchardWedding Cakes Cake Creations412 N Main St # 3New Carlisle, OH, 453449378459710BakeriesBakeryBirthday CakesCake BakeryCake Creations Supply ShopCake Supply StoreCupcake BakeryCupcakesDonutsStevens Bakery And OrchardWedding Cakes Show More