Hardware Stores in Caldwell, OH Hayes True Value401 Main StCaldwell, OH, 437247407324225Garden CentersGarden StatuesHardware StoresPlumbing SupplyReliable SupplyTrue Value HardwareVillage HardwareYard Ornaments Caldwell Lumber Co.17990 Woodsfield RdCaldwell, OH, 437247407322306Hardware StoresPlumbing Supply Show MoreSee AlsoPaint